👋 Hey {{first name | DistillED reader!}}

Brett Benson here… In this special guest edition, we're unpacking a simple idea that just might change how you plan every lesson, and what it looks like in practice.

The inspiration comes from one of the more famous lines in all of cognitive psychology: memory is the residue of thought. So, as you plan, beware of the biscuit. More on that shortly.

In this edition

📊 Do Now: Quick Poll!

What Is 'Memory Is the Residue of Thought'?

At its core, cognitive scientist Daniel Willingham's idea in Why Don't Students Like School? is simple: we remember what we think about, not merely what we see, hear or do. Whatever is on a student's mind in the moment is what they are most likely to remember down the road (Willingham, 2009).

Willingham shares a great classroom example. A fourth-grade teacher had students bake biscuits during an Underground Railroad unit, since biscuits were a staple food for people escaping slavery. Fun, right? But Willingham pointed out that students probably spent about 40 seconds thinking about how biscuits connect to the Underground Railroad and 40 minutes thinking about measuring flour. Guess what they remembered most? How to make a biscuit! Because that is what they thought about the most. So, in planning lessons, we must beware of the biscuit.

Imagine two diners being served by the same waiter at a restaurant. One notices the waiter's unusual accent and spends the meal wondering where it comes from, listening closely to how he pronounces certain words. The other is fascinated by the waiter's unusual beard, paying attention to its shape and appearance. Both see and hear the same person, but each focuses on something different.

A few days later, the first diner remembers the waiter's distinctive accent, while the second recalls his unusual beard. Neither has a better memory. They simply thought about different things during the same experience. Same input, different thinking, different memory.

In typical DistillED fashion, here's what memory as the residue of thought is, and what it isn't:

👎 Memory as the Residue of Thought IS NOT:

  • Activity or Artifact → Being busy, or finishing a beautiful product, doesn't mean anyone thought hard about the content. Beware the biscuit!

  • Engagement Theater → Lively conversation and collaboration can look great while gilding shallow, off-task thinking.

  • Trying Harder to Remember → "Memorize this" doesn't work, because students don't know what to do to make something memorable.

👍 Memory as the Residue of Thought IS:

  • Thinking-Driven → What students think about is what they remember, right down to the specific details their thinking focuses on.

  • Individual → Prior knowledge and interests shape what each student focuses on, so no two students walk away with identical memories.

  • Designable → You can plan for it by designing tasks where thinking about the meaning is hard to avoid.

DistillED+ in Practice

Learn how Deputy Principal Michael Swanborough uses DistillED+ materials at St Andrews Christian College in Melbourne to boost professional dialogue.

Why Does It Matter?

Willingham argues that reviewing each lesson plan in terms of what students are likely to think about may be the single most useful idea cognitive psychology has to offer teachers.

❝

"Memory is the residue of thought."

Daniel Willingham, Why Don't Students Like School? (2009)

Why does it matter so much? Because every student's brain runs on the same basic architecture: environment, attention, working memory, long-term memory, remembering and forgetting. That shared structure is the only reason teaching thirty students at once works at all. Of course, differences in background knowledge, working memory capacity and attention are exactly what make it so hard, and why thinking needs to be planned for with intentionality and purpose.

This diagram is inspired by Oliver Caviglioli’s original interpretation of Willingham’s model.

👉 Read more on that shared architecture here: The Simple Model of the Mind

Ironically, students are usually bad at knowing how their own memory works. Tell them "I'll test you on this word list later" and it doesn't help much, because they don't know what to do to make the words stick. But ask them to think about and rate how much they like each word, and they will probably remember the list quite well.

Héctor Ruiz Martín makes a similar point for classroom instruction in How Do We Learn?: learning activities should be designed so that students spend their mental effort thinking about the learning object itself, meaning the knowledge, concepts and relationships we want them to understand and remember. This means anticipating what students are likely to pay attention to at each stage of a lesson and making sure their thinking is directed toward what matters most (Ruiz Martín, 2024).

Activities should prepare students to think about the target content in the same way they will be expected to think about it later on assessments, whether that means identifying patterns, explaining cause-and-effect relationships, comparing examples or applying their knowledge in a new context. Details that add context or make a task more visually appealing can be useful, but only when they support this purpose. When seductive details, elaborate structures or unnecessary features compete for students' attention, they risk becoming the focus of students' thinking rather than the content itself.

When we don't account for what students are likely to think about, they end up thinking about things we don't need them to remember. Willingham tells a story about his nephew, who was asked to draw a plot diagram of a book with pictures for each plot element (Willingham, 2009, p. 68). Consequently, he thought very little about how the elements connected and a great deal about drawing good pictures. His daughter's teacher, by contrast, asked for words and short phrases instead. That version worked better because she had to think about how the ideas connect, not about how to draw a really nice castle or rainbow.

👉 Read more on why busy-looking lessons can mislead us here: Poor Proxies #2: The Engagement Myth

🎯 Teaching for Attention Playbook

My new Teaching for Attention Playbook is a 70+ page, evidence-informed guide that breaks down the science of attention and provides 6 practical strategies to support teachers.

How Do I Put It Into Practice?

So how do we bring this principle to life in the classroom? Start with two questions: What do I need students to remember? and How will I get every student to think meaningfully about it? The first identifies your learning object and target details. The second determines your plan for thinking and participation.

Below is the structure I use daily to make meaningful thinking about the learning objective and target details unavoidable for every student. I'll use a first-day-of-school lesson built around Seven Blind Mice as the running example.

Step

Explanation

Example

1. Name the Target Details


→ Purpose: Know exactly what you want remembered before you plan anything else.

Before choosing any learning activities, write down the exact target details students need to know and remember. Then choose every prompt, question and technique to point at those details.

"For this story, I want them to remember the colors of the mice and what each one thought the Something was."

2. Run the Thinking Test


→ Purpose: Spot the seductive details before your students spend time thinking about them.

For any task, ask yourself: what will they actually be thinking about? Not doing, thinking. If the honest answer is layout, coloring or who's doing what, rework the task until the content is the only thing to think about. Make it unavoidable.

Instead of asking students to draw their favorite mouse: "Match each mouse's color to what it thought the Something was, and explain how each mouse's limited perspective shaped its conclusion."

3. Make Thinking Overt


→ Purpose: Get everyone thinking about the target details, not just the eager hands and minds.

Use techniques with high rates of thinking and participation where nobody can quietly check out: call and response, turn and talk, Stop and Jot, think-pair-share, mini-whiteboards, cold call, hinge questions, checks for listening and all-hands-up.

Call and response: "What did the green mouse think the Something was?" "A snake!"

MWB: "Rank each mouse's observation from most to least accurate. Write it, hold it up."

Cold call: "3…2…1…all hands up! Theo, which was most accurate?"

4. Pick a Visible Thinking Routine


→ Purpose: Make meaningful thinking unavoidable and easy to see.

Match a Harvard Project Zero thinking routine to your goal: Compass Points to summarise, Circle of Viewpoints to analyse, 3-2-1 Bridge to synthesise, Claim-Support-Question to evaluate. Introduce it, let students write quietly first, then share in pairs, on whiteboards and by cold call.

"Today we're using Claim-Support-Question to build an argument: The ____ mouse was the most blind. The ____ mouse was the least blind. Write your claims, your support, and one question you still have."

5. Bring It Back Tomorrow, Then Tell Them Why


→ Purpose: Check the memory and teach students how memory works.

Open the next lesson with a Do Now that asks students to retrieve the target details from memory, and keep revisiting them in the weeks after. Next-day retrieval is the real test of a lesson's effectiveness.

Do Now: "Write the colors and what each mouse mistook the Something for."

Afterwards: "Remember how I kept asking about the mice? You talked, wrote and answered together. You remember it because you thought about it."

In my Seven Blind Mice lesson, knowing my target details ahead of time meant I could plan every prompt, routine and question around getting students to think about them again and again. The next day, my students crushed the Do Now. Why? Because they were continually and explicitly prompted to think meaningfully about the target details and learning object of the lesson. There were no biscuits to beware of in my lesson plan.

Putting this into practice is pretty straightforward. Pull up one of your existing lesson plans and work through each part of the lesson, asking yourself: What are my students most likely thinking about right now? Not what are they doing, what materials are they using or what activity are they completing, but what is actually occupying their working memory?

In other words, beware of the biscuit! If students are so focused on the "biscuit" that they miss the object of the lesson, the biscuit may become the very thing they remember most. Students may remember the colourful poster they made, the game they played or the materials they used rather than the knowledge we intended to teach. The goal isn't to eliminate engaging activities or enjoyable experiences. It's to make sure the content, rather than the activity surrounding it, becomes the primary object of students' thinking.

— Brett Benson

If you want more:

👉 Read The Simple Model of the Mind: the shared architecture behind why we remember what we think about

👉 Read Poor Proxies #2: The Engagement Myth: why a busy, lively lesson isn't proof that anyone thought hard

👉 Read Everyone, Together, Anyone: more ways to make thinking overt for every student, as in step 3

👉 Read The 'Do Now': how to open tomorrow's lesson by checking what stuck, as in step 5

📥 Free One-Page Guide

Memory is the Residue of Thought One-Page Guide
To help you put this into practice, download the Memory is the Residue of Thought one-page guide: Brett's five steps for making meaningful thinking unavoidable, from naming your target details to bringing them back the next day. Useful for your own planning, in coaching conversations, or during team PD.

Subscribe for free content

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to ⚗️DistillED to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Recommended for you

View All
caret-right